| Gandalf the White Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 3 | | $18.56 / $7.88 | |
| Sol Ring Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 76 | 19% | $13 / $7 | |
| Cavern-Hoard Dragon Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 61 | | $11.99 / $5.9 | |
| Gandalf, Friend of the Shire Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 5 | 6% | $10.49 / $5.09 | |
| Lord of the Nazgûl Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 64 | | $8.64 / $1.88 | |
| Samwise the Stouthearted Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 39 | | $7.7 / $4.99 | |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 21 | -2% | $6.3 / $5.11 | |
| Aragorn, King of Gondor Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 57 | 3% | $4.5 / $1.59 | |
| Witch-king of Angmar Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 43 | -1% | $4.17 / $3.54 | |
| Nazgûl Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 53 | | $4.01 / $2.63 | |
| Heroic Intervention Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 73 | 3% | $3.39 / $1 | |
| Goldberry, River-Daughter Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 6 | -1% | $3.03 / $1.95 | |
| The Balrog, Flame of Udûn Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 36 | | $2.92 / $1.82 | |
| Boromir, Warden of the Tower Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 1 | | $2.69 / $0.99 | |
| Plains Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 30 | 1% | $2.63 / $2.25 | |
| Galadriel of Lothlórien Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 48 | 1% | $2.53 / $0.47 | |
| Frodo Baggins Art Card (47/81) (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 47 | 1% | $2.51 / $1.6 | |
| Shadow of the Enemy Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 8 | | $2.34 / $1 | |
| Tom Bombadil Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 26 | | $2.31 / $2 | |
| Minas Tirith Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 55 | 3% | $2.24 / $2.16 | |
| Commander's Sphere Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 75 | -1% | $2.04 / $1 | |
| The Mouth of Sauron Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 18 | | $2 / $1.35 | |
| Valley of Gorgoroth Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 80 | | $2 / $2 | |
| Treefolk Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 81 | 4% | $1.86 / $1.45 | |
| Bilbo's Ring Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 37 | 1% | $1.85 / $0.97 | |
| The Dead Marshes Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 79 | 1% | $1.84 / $0.99 | |
| Saruman of Many Colors Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 20 | | $1.78 / $0.8 | |
| Legolas, Master Archer Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 45 | 1% | $1.78 / $1.1 | |
| Learn from the Past Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 70 | | $1.74 / $0.5 | |
| Gollum, Patient Plotter Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 41 | | $1.73 / $0.5 | |
| Faramir, Steward of Gondor Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 62 | | $1.72 / $0.75 | |
| Mountain Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 31 | -1% | $1.67 / $0.79 | |
| Merry, Warden of Isengard Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 65 | 2% | $1.67 / $0.95 | |
| Generous Ent Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 11 | 4% | $1.64 / $1 | |
| Gimli, Counter of Kills Art Card (44/81) (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 44 | -1% | $1.64 / $0.99 | |
| Realm Seekers Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 74 | 2% | $1.64 / $0.51 | |
| Sméagol, Helpful Guide Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 24 | | $1.63 / $0.96 | |
| Sharkey, Tyrant of the Shire Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 22 | | $1.62 / $1.13 | |
| Arwen Undómiel Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 13 | -1% | $1.56 / $0.46 | |
| Pippin, Warden of Isengard Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 66 | 5% | $1.55 / $0.4 | |
| Barad-dûr Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 54 | -1% | $1.53 / $0.5 | |
| Gimli, Counter of Kills Art Card (10/81) (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 10 | -2% | $1.5 / $1 | |
| Merry, Esquire of Rohan Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 50 | -1% | $1.5 / $0.82 | |
| Boon of the Wish-Giver Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 69 | 1% | $1.48 / $1.02 | |
| Field of Ruin Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 77 | -2% | $1.45 / $0.56 | |
| Samwise Gamgee Art Card (19/81) (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 19 | 1% | $1.43 / $0.75 | |
| Marshal's Anthem Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 68 | | $1.43 / $0.49 | |
| Aragorn and Arwen, Wed Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 33 | | $1.42 / $0.7 | |
| Galadriel, Gift-Giver Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 35 | 6% | $1.41 / $1 | |
| Legolas, Counter of Kills Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 17 | | $1.37 / $0.85 | |
| Andúril, Flame of the West Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 28 | | $1.34 / $0.49 | |
| Sam, Loyal Attendant Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 58 | | $1.32 / $0.75 | |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 34 | 1% | $1.3 / $0.75 | |
| Asceticism Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 72 | -1% | $1.3 / $0.97 | |
| Pippin, Guard of the Citadel Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 51 | 1% | $1.27 / $1 | |
| Sauron, the Necromancer Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 42 | | $1.24 / $0.5 | |
| Fog on the Barrow-Downs Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 2 | 1% | $1.2 / $0.94 | |
| Elrond, Lord of Rivendell Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 40 | -3% | $1.19 / $0.43 | |
| Took Reaper Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 4 | -2% | $1.16 / $0.5 | |
| Bilbo, Retired Burglar Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 14 | | $1.13 / $0.5 | |
| Samwise Gamgee Art Card (52/81) (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 52 | 1% | $1.06 / $0.9 | |
| Théoden, King of Rohan Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 25 | 1% | $1 / $0.47 | |
| Mines of Moria Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 56 | | $0.99 / $0.75 | |
| Call for Aid Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 60 | -6% | $0.98 / $0.75 | |
| Gríma, Saruman's Footman Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 63 | 2% | $0.96 / $0.25 | |
| Gwaihir, Greatest of the Eagles Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 59 | 4% | $0.95 / $0.2 | |
| Gandalf the Grey Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 49 | | $0.92 / $0.62 | |
| The Watcher in the Water Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 7 | 2% | $0.89 / $0.21 | |
| Faramir, Field Commander Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 38 | | $0.86 / $0.35 | |
| Horn of Gondor Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 29 | | $0.83 / $0.25 | |
| Aragorn, the Uniter Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 46 | | $0.83 / $0.5 | |
| Nazgûl Art Card | Common | 53 | -1% | $0.81 / $0.3 | |
| Éomer of the Riddermark Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 9 | | $0.8 / $0.6 | |
| Shelob, Child of Ungoliant Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 23 | | $0.8 / $0.55 | |
| Mirrormere Guardian Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 12 | | $0.77 / $0.55 | |
| Thrill of Possibility Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 71 | 2% | $0.77 / $0.43 | |
| Elanor Gardner Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 32 | | $0.7 / $0.49 | |
| Frodo Baggins Art Card (16/81) (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 16 | 3% | $0.67 / $0.46 | |
| Treebeard, Gracious Host Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 67 | | $0.63 / $0.4 | |
| Uglúk of the White Hand Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 27 | -3% | $0.6 / $0.45 | |
| Éowyn, Fearless Knight Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 15 | | $0.59 / $0.44 | |
| Sol Ring Art Card | Common | 76 | -1% | $0.5 / $0.15 | |
| Ghost Quarter Art Card (Gold-Stamped Signature) | Common | 78 | | $0.49 / $0.22 | |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord Art Card | Common | 21 | | $0.32 / $0.11 | |
| Minas Tirith Art Card | Common | 55 | | $0.3 / $0.11 | |
| Cavern-Hoard Dragon Art Card | Common | 61 | | $0.26 / $0.1 | |
| Gandalf the White Art Card | Common | 3 | 4% | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Goldberry, River-Daughter Art Card | Common | 6 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Gimli, Counter of Kills Art Card (10/81) | Common | 10 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Arwen Undómiel Art Card | Common | 13 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Éowyn, Fearless Knight Art Card | Common | 15 | | $0.25 / $0.08 | |
| Legolas, Counter of Kills Art Card | Common | 17 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Samwise Gamgee Art Card (19/81) | Common | 19 | | $0.25 / $0.06 | |
| Sméagol, Helpful Guide Art Card | Common | 24 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Théoden, King of Rohan Art Card | Common | 25 | | $0.25 / $0.09 | |
| Mountain Art Card | Common | 31 | | $0.25 / $0.07 | |
| Aragorn and Arwen, Wed Art Card | Common | 33 | 6% | $0.25 / $0.07 | |
| Samwise the Stouthearted Art Card | Common | 39 | | $0.25 / $0.03 | |
| Elrond, Lord of Rivendell Art Card | Common | 40 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Gimli, Counter of Kills Art Card (44/81) | Common | 44 | | $0.25 / $0.03 | |
| Aragorn, the Uniter Art Card | Common | 46 | | $0.25 / $0.03 | |
| Galadriel of Lothlórien Art Card | Common | 48 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Gandalf the Grey Art Card | Common | 49 | 6% | $0.25 / $0.05 | |
| Samwise Gamgee Art Card (52/81) | Common | 52 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Aragorn, King of Gondor Art Card | Common | 57 | 4% | $0.25 / $0.01 | |
| Lord of the Nazgûl Art Card | Common | 64 | | $0.25 / $0.05 | |
| Learn from the Past Art Card | Common | 70 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Asceticism Art Card | Common | 72 | | $0.25 / $0.05 | |
| Realm Seekers Art Card | Common | 74 | | $0.25 / $0.05 | |
| Commander's Sphere Art Card | Common | 75 | | $0.25 / $0.08 | |
| The Dead Marshes Art Card | Common | 79 | | $0.25 / $0.01 | |
| Valley of Gorgoroth Art Card | Common | 80 | | $0.25 / $0.08 | |
| Treefolk Art Cards | Common | 81 | | $0.25 / $0.1 | |
| Gandalf, Friend of the Shire Art Card | Common | 5 | | $0.24 / $0.01 | |
| Frodo Baggins Art Card (47/81) | Common | 47 | 8% | $0.24 / $0.09 | |
| Pippin, Guard of the Citadel Art Card | Common | 51 | | $0.24 / $0.04 | |
| Gríma, Saruman's Footman Art Card | Common | 63 | | $0.24 / $0.05 | |
| Heroic Intervention Art Card | Common | 73 | | $0.24 / $0.1 | |
| Merry, Esquire of Rohan Art Card | Common | 50 | 6% | $0.23 / $0.05 | |
| Field of Ruin Art Card | Common | 77 | | $0.23 / $0.05 | |
| Shelob, Child of Ungoliant Art Card | Common | 23 | 8% | $0.22 / $0.05 | |
| Plains Art Card | Common | 30 | | $0.22 / $0.1 | |
| Gollum, Patient Plotter Art Card | Common | 41 | 6% | $0.22 / $0.1 | |
| Sauron, the Necromancer Art Card | Common | 42 | | $0.22 / $0.15 | |
| Mines of Moria Art Card | Common | 56 | | $0.22 / $0.03 | |
| Boon of the Wish-Giver Art Card | Common | 69 | | $0.22 / $0.03 | |
| Boromir, Warden of the Tower Art Card | Common | 1 | | $0.21 / $0.08 | |
| The Watcher in the Water Art Card | Common | 7 | | $0.21 / $0.05 | |
| Éomer of the Riddermark Art Card | Common | 9 | | $0.21 / $0.1 | |
| Bilbo, Retired Burglar Art Card | Common | 14 | | $0.21 / $0.08 | |
| Andúril, Flame of the West Art Card | Common | 28 | | $0.21 / $0.01 | |
| Horn of Gondor Art Card | Common | 29 | | $0.21 / $0.09 | |
| Elanor Gardner Art Card | Common | 32 | 6% | $0.21 / $0.05 | |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin Art Card | Common | 34 | | $0.21 / $0.08 | |
| Barad-dûr Art Card | Common | 54 | | $0.21 / $0.1 | |
| Pippin, Warden of Isengard Art Card | Common | 66 | 9% | $0.21 / $0.01 | |
| Marshal's Anthem Art Card | Common | 68 | | $0.21 / $0.05 | |
| Fog on the Barrow-Downs Art Card | Common | 2 | 7% | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Took Reaper Art Card | Common | 4 | 6% | $0.2 / $0.03 | |
| Shadow of the Enemy Art Card | Common | 8 | | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Generous Ent Art Card | Common | 11 | | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Mirrormere Guardian Art Card | Common | 12 | | $0.2 / $0.04 | |
| Frodo Baggins Art Card (16/81) | Common | 16 | | $0.2 / $0.05 | |
| The Mouth of Sauron Art Card | Common | 18 | | $0.2 / $0.1 | |
| Saruman of Many Colors Art Card | Common | 20 | -6% | $0.2 / $0.12 | |
| Sharkey, Tyrant of the Shire Art Card | Common | 22 | 7% | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Tom Bombadil Art Card | Common | 26 | | $0.2 / $0.08 | |
| Galadriel, Gift-Giver Art Card | Common | 35 | | $0.2 / $0.07 | |
| The Balrog, Flame of Udûn Art Card | Common | 36 | | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Bilbo's Ring Art Card | Common | 37 | | $0.2 / $0.08 | |
| Legolas, Master Archer Art Card | Common | 45 | 6% | $0.2 / $0.05 | |
| Sam, Loyal Attendant Art Card | Common | 58 | | $0.2 / $0.09 | |
| Gwaihir, Greatest of the Eagles Art Card | Common | 59 | | $0.2 / $0.05 | |
| Call for Aid Art Card | Common | 60 | | $0.2 / $0.03 | |
| Faramir, Steward of Gondor Art Card | Common | 62 | | $0.2 / $0.03 | |
| Merry, Warden of Isengard Art Card | Common | 65 | | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Treebeard, Gracious Host Art Card | Common | 67 | | $0.2 / $0.1 | |
| Thrill of Possibility Art Card | Common | 71 | | $0.2 / $0.01 | |
| Ghost Quarter Art Card | Common | 78 | | $0.2 / $0.05 | |
| Faramir, Field Commander Art Card | Common | 38 | | $0.19 / $0.01 | |
| Witch-king of Angmar Art Card | Common | 43 | | $0.19 / $0.05 | |
| Uglúk of the White Hand Art Card | Common | 27 | | $0.18 / $0.01 | |
