Nightmare card image from Limited Edition Alpha
5b

Magic the Gathering MTG
Nightmare

MTG Nightmare was first printed in Limited Edition Alpha. There are 45 total variations.

Receive weekly updates on your collection.

Free membership gives you access to collection tracking and user-only features.

Create a Free Account
img Set Mid Foil
Nightmare card from Limited Edition Alpha Limited Edition Alpha's Nightmare
Nightmare card from Limited Edition Beta Limited Edition Beta's Nightmare $1016.49
Nightmare card from Unlimited Edition Unlimited Edition's Nightmare $96.99
Nightmare card from Revised Edition Revised Edition's Nightmare $5.7
Nightmare card from Fourth Edition Fourth Edition's Nightmare $1.25
Nightmare card from Fifth Edition Fifth Edition's Nightmare $0.94
Nightmare card from Classic Sixth Edition Classic Sixth Edition's Nightmare $0.85
Nightmare card from Seventh Edition Seventh Edition's Nightmare $0.5
Nightmare card from Eighth Edition Eighth Edition's Nightmare $0.4 $2.1
Nightmare Lash card from Mirrodin Mirrodin's Nightmare Lash $3.85 $11.22
Nightmare card from Ninth Edition Ninth Edition's Nightmare $0.4
Nightmare Void card from Ravnica: City of Guilds Ravnica: City of Guilds's Nightmare Void $0.25 $0.42
Nightmare card from Tenth Edition Tenth Edition's Nightmare $0.5 $1.42
Nightmare Incursion card from Eventide Eventide's Nightmare Incursion $1.27 $7.24
Nightmare card from Magic 2010 Magic 2010's Nightmare $0.43 $0.47
Nightmare Void card from Duel Decks: Izzet vs. Golgari Duel Decks: Izzet vs. Golgari's Nightmare Void $0.25
Nightmare card from Magic 2014 Core Set Magic 2014 Core Set's Nightmare $0.3 $0.98
Nightmare card from Magic 2015 Core Set Magic 2015 Core Set's Nightmare $0.25
Nightmare card from Magic Origins Magic Origins's Nightmare $0.25
Nightmare card from Welcome Deck 2016 Welcome Deck 2016's Nightmare $0.25
Nightmare's Thirst card from Core Set 2019 Core Set 2019's Nightmare's Thirst $0.22 $0.37
Nightmare (CE) card from Collector's Edition Collector's Edition's Nightmare (CE) $23.26
Nightmare (IE) card from International Edition International Edition's Nightmare (IE) $29.69
Nightmare card from Welcome Deck 2017 Welcome Deck 2017's Nightmare $0.25
Nightmare Horror Token card from Dominaria Dominaria's Nightmare Horror Token $0.25
Nightmare Unmaking card from Commander 2019 Commander 2019's Nightmare Unmaking $0.3
Nightmare Moon // Princess Luna card from Ponies: The Galloping Ponies: The Galloping's Nightmare Moon // Princess Luna $90.96
Nightmare Shepherd card from Theros Beyond Death Theros Beyond Death's Nightmare Shepherd $0.5 $0.48
Nightmare Shepherd (Extended Art) card from Theros Beyond Death Theros Beyond Death's Nightmare Shepherd (Extended Art) $1.9 $4.55
Nightmare Token card from Theros Beyond Death Theros Beyond Death's Nightmare Token $0.42
Nightmare Shepherd card from Promo Pack: Theros Beyond Death Promo Pack: Theros Beyond Death's Nightmare Shepherd $0.59 $0.63
Nightmare Shepherd card from Prerelease Cards Prerelease Cards's Nightmare Shepherd $1.31
Nightmare card from Revised Edition (Foreign Black Border) Revised Edition (Foreign Black Border)'s Nightmare
Nightmare card from The List The List's Nightmare $0.34
Nightmare Unmaking card from New Capenna Commander New Capenna Commander's Nightmare Unmaking $0.3
Nightmare card from 30th Anniversary Edition 30th Anniversary Edition's Nightmare $34.22
Nightmare (Retro Frame) card from 30th Anniversary Edition 30th Anniversary Edition's Nightmare (Retro Frame) $245
Nightmare Unmaking card from Wilds of Eldraine Commander Wilds of Eldraine Commander's Nightmare Unmaking $0.25
Nightmare // Food (0010) Double-Sided Token card from Wilds of Eldraine Wilds of Eldraine's Nightmare // Food (0010) Double-Sided Token $0.21
Nightmare // Food (0011) Double-Sided Token card from Wilds of Eldraine Wilds of Eldraine's Nightmare // Food (0011) Double-Sided Token $0.21
Nightmare // Food (0012) Double-Sided Token card from Wilds of Eldraine Wilds of Eldraine's Nightmare // Food (0012) Double-Sided Token $0.24
Nightmare // Food (0013) Double-Sided Token card from Wilds of Eldraine Wilds of Eldraine's Nightmare // Food (0013) Double-Sided Token $0.28
Nightmare Token card from Wilds of Eldraine Wilds of Eldraine's Nightmare Token $0.2
Nightmare Shepherd card from Commander: Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander: Duskmourn: House of Horror's Nightmare Shepherd $0.3
Nightmare card from Fourth Edition (Foreign Black Border) Fourth Edition (Foreign Black Border)'s Nightmare

Prices update once daily at 9am eastern standard time. Prices provided by TCGplayer.com

EchoMTG is a financial tracking collection tool for people who collect Magic: the Gathering cards™. It's created for you to track your collection while knowing its day-to-day value. Create an account today.

Chat with us via Twitter or Email

EchoMTG © 2012-25. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy & Terms & Conditions.

All Magic: the Gathering™ and it's respective properties references are © Wizards of the Coast.